Selling cards can be a bit stressful for someone new to the hobby. While many sell directly on eBay, it can seem intimidating. What details do I need? How do I ship my cards? How do I maximize value? What if something goes wrong?

Or if you are sitting on tons of quantity - those $5+ hits that just seem to accumulate over time, is all that eBay listing, supplies and effort worth it?

Along the way, you have likely heard about consignment services. Companies like COMC, Quick Consign, DCSports87, and Hoody’s Collectibles specialize in this space for different reasons. But how do you choose the right one? We tried all four this year to figure it out. Let’s break it down.

You can't go wrong with any of these companies. Across the board we had a great experience, including in some instances where we needed legitimate support. They have subtle differences that are worth understanding, however.

Consignment Services

Consignment shops retain ownership of your cards until they are sold, and the consignment service handles listing, selling, and shipping. They take a percentage of the sale price as a fee. In some cases this fee can be below what you would need to pay someone like eBay directly - as these companies can operate at higher bulk and negotiate better rates.

COMC (CheckOutMyCards): The Bulk Seller’s Friend

If you’ve got a shoebox full of cards—especially in the $1–$50 range—COMC is a solid choice. They offer several service levels:

Standard: $0.50 per card, 16-week turnaround (great for low-end, bulk cards)
Select: $1 per card, 2-week turnaround (for mid-range cards)
Elite: $2 per card, 2-week turnaround (for high-value cards, $50+)
eBay Auctions: For cards $80+, they’ll send them directly to eBay for auction

Why use COMC?

Your cards get listed on COMC and eBay automatically—so tons of eyeballs see them.
They’ve partnered with PSA for grading, and you can send in already-graded cards too.
Fees are clear: 5% when your card sells, plus a 10% cash-out fee if you want your money. Or use it as store credit and upgrade to a big card.

Downsides?

It can be slow, especially for the cheapest tier.
They don’t handle memorabilia like baseballs or jerseys—just cards and flat collectibles.

Quick Consign: Fast, Simple, and eBay-Focused

Want your money quickly and don’t want to fuss with listing? Quick Consign is all about speed and simplicity.

Payouts: 85%–95% of the sale price, depending on card value (the higher the value, the higher your cut)
How it works: Ship your cards in toploaders and team bags, they do the rest—photos, listings, shipping, and payments.
Payments: Paid out weekly — in cash via PayPal, check or direct deposit

Best for:

Mid- to high-value cards ($10–$5,000+)
Sellers who want a hands-off, fast process. Ship and forget the cards exist

Downsides:

They only sell on eBay
If your cards don’t sell, they are “donated” (so make sure they're worth a $5+!)
Very simple photos based on what you send it in—make sure your toploaders are clean

DCSports87: eBay Auction Experts

If you love the thrill of the auction and have high-end cards to move, DCSports87 is worth a look.

Payouts: 80%–97% depending on card value (lower for cheap cards, higher for expensive ones)
Listing speed: Express service gets your cards up in 3 days; standard is about 2 weeks
Tracking: You get a dashboard to watch your cards’ progress and payouts happen multiple times a week. They have a top cards homepage

Why try DCSports87?

They have a strong eBay following, which can mean higher bids
Great for high-value or in-demand cards

Things to note:

Lower payouts for cheap cards (under $10)
No memorabilia—just cards

Hoody’s Collectibles: The Memorabilia Specialist

Got a signed baseball, jersey, or something unique? Hoody’s stands out because they handle all kinds of memorabilia—not just cards. Note that we only tried them for memorabilia—but based on that experience, we'll definitely give them a try for cards as well in the near future.

Retail locations in Oregon for in-person drop-offs
Fast auctions—your item is listed within 10 days
Handles everything: Cards, autographed memorabilia, jerseys, and more

Pros:

They offer grading services as well
Perfect if you want to sell more than just cards
They come across as a bit of a more premium experience—from the website to the customer service. They'll take care of you

Downsides:

Higher rates, especially the 20% for memorabilia, is a tough pill to swallow—but maybe necessary considering the shipping considerations

Auction vs. Buy It Now: Which Sells Better?

Auctions can be better for hot, in-demand cards—bidding wars can push prices up
Buy It Now works better if you think prices could rise, or just feel confident your value is the right one

Grading: Boost Your Card’s Value

PSA is the top dog for grading, with 1.45 million cards graded monthly. eBay even offers direct PSA grading for $39.99 on cards valued at $250+
SGC is known for speed and value
BGS and CGC are also solid options, each with their own perks. The BGS black label pristine is well regarded still as a notch above a PSA 10

What’s Best for Your Cards?

Bulk, low-value cards ($1–$5): COMC Standard
Mid-value cards ($10–$50): COMC Select or QuickConsign
High-value cards ($50–$250+): Any of them! Hoody's, COMC Elite, Quick Consign, or DCSports87
Memorabilia (baseballs, jerseys): Hoody’s

Final Tips

Always check the latest fees and read the fine print
Consider grading for valuable cards—it can make a big difference. And consider the opposite—grading a low-end card is rarely worth it in the long run
Think about whether you want to auction or set a price
For memorabilia, choose a service with experience in more than just cards

Thinking about selling? Drop your questions or share your own experiences on Instagram @hobbymonitor! The hobby is always changing, and the best choice is the one that fits your collection and your style.

Hobby Tested: Which Sports Card Consignment Service Is Right for You?